Best Mattress for Overweight Couples of 2018 & Buying Guide

Buying a new mattress as a couple is complicated enough.  There are two people to accommodate, which is tough if you have different preferences, positions, and sleeping temperatures.  For overweight couples (or folks with higher BMIs overall), the search becomes even harder.  Most mattresses are designed for lighter or average-weight people, and what works for them might seriously lack support for anyone heavier.

In this buyer’s guide, we’ll explore why most mattresses aren’t suited to heavier individuals, and evaluate some of the best models on today’s market for overweight couples tired of making do with uncomfortable beds.

Note: you may or may not be classified as overweight, depending on your height and individual physiology.  For the purpose of this buyer’s guide, “heavy,” “overweight,” and similar terms will refer to a weight of 200 lbs. or greater.

Why should we consider a mattress designed for heavier couples?

Would you buy a bike with a maximum weight capacity of 150 lbs., if you weigh 250?  Or expect any sized adult to find comfort in a chair meant for teenagers?

Different products are designed with particular needs in mind, and their performance and structural integrity are often dictated, among other things, by our weights and heights.  Mattresses are no different.  Unfortunately, overweight people are often overlooked in almost every product category…especially mattresses.

Ones to suit heavy folks do exist, though, and can provide you with the good night’s sleep you deserve.  Just as properly designed clothing feels better, so can the correct mattres.

Product

Quality

Our Rating

Price

Signature Sleep Signature 13

A+

Gramercy Euro-Top Cool-Gel

A+

Eco Terra 11

Ultimate Sleep Overweight

A-

Buying Guides

___________________________________________________________________________

Our average-weight friends loved their mattress, so we got the same one—but it’s so uncomfortable for us!Why are some models not ideal for heavier couples?

This is always disheartening, because life is much simpler when we can trust the reviews and advice of those nearest and dearest to us—but in the case of beds, what works for one couple might be awful for another.

The bottom line is that your friends’ mattress was designed for light or average weights.  That’s the way it was made, and it can only withstand so much weight before its performance becomes compromised.  Maybe the support layer isn’t thick enough for your needs, or the gel-infused top layer just can’t disperse your body heat fast enough.  Whatever the reason, this mattress wasn’t made for overweight people.

Second, not all companies will tell you what weight range their mattresses are best for, largely because they don’t know themselves!  There are a lot of brands that don’t test this, don’t think to include it in descriptions, etc.  While more reputable brands should be able to tell you (either in the specs list, or through customer service representatives), your best bet is to read customer reviews.  Chances are, you’ll find at least a few from people weighing similar amounts as you, and they’ll evaluate that model in a way average-sized or lighter people can’t.

Which factors make a mattress better for sleepers of a higher weight?

There are a few aspects to look at in potential purchases when deciding if it will provide you and your partner with the best sleep possible.  Thickness is the most important one, overall, but a lot of buyers don’t pay this much mind unless they’re shopping to fit a unique bed (such as a pull-out sofa).  Thicker mattresses will provide more support than thin ones—but it also depends on what the bed is made of, and how much of each material it contains.

For example, an 8” mattress might have 4” of support foam at the bottom, which is very firm.  Next, there could be a 2” transition foam layer, 1” of cooling foam, and 1” of memory foam.   Overweight people will compress the top layers more than someone of average weight, and might get a “sinking” or trapped feeling, instead of contouring support.  In a mattress with extra inches of foam in those first 3 layers, however, the support will be higher.  This is why, overall, a thicker mattress (with generous layers) is better for heavy people.

Another factor is firmness.  Medium to firm models will sink less, and therefore support your frame much more.  Edge support is also important, so the mattress doesn’t compress too much when you sit on it or roll towards the side in your sleep.  Many models have reinforced edges now, and should state so in the product description.

Lastly, consider your ventilation needs.  In general, larger individuals tend to run hotter, especially while sleeping.  Innerspring models and hybrids (which have innersprings and memory foam) provide excellent ventilation compared to all-foam models, although even the latter works to combat nighttime heat via gel infusions, foam substitutions, and airflow channels.  This isn’t a problem for everyone, overweight or otherwise, so if you and your partner sleep cool, don’t worry about those features.

Do heavier people need to replace their mattress more often?

Overall, yes.  Even mattresses designed for your bodyweight will break down faster, because your body sinks into it more.  While the base layer (or innersprings, as applicable) might hold up just fine, those top foam layers are likely to flatten as time goes on.

That said, some mattresses can still hold up exceptionally well, and one meant for heavier people will definitely last longer for you than one meant for average weight.  Regardless of your weight, most mattresses will need replacing in 5 to 10 years, with 7 being the average before people notice sagging, permanent indentations, slower response time, etc.

Related Post:  Best Memory Foam Mattress of 2018 & Buying Guide

I’m lighter/average weight, but my partner is heavier.  What should we be looking for?

This is a very difficult compromise to find.  When one partner is significantly heavier than the other, a lot of mattresses don’t really know how to accommodate that.  If it’s too soft, the heavier partner will sink too much, and the lighter partner might roll towards them in the night.  If it’s firm enough for the overweight sleeper’s comfort, it’s very possible the lighter one will wake up with aches and pains from insufficient pressure point relief.

Ultimate Sleep Overweight

Ultimate Sleep Overweight

So, what’s a pair of mismatched lovebirds to do?  Fortunately, today’s market is all about customization.  The easiest solution is an adjustable mattress, such as a Sleep Number or something similar.  These beds are separated in two, so each side can be changed to the exact firmness or softness (and on some models, even temperature) that partner prefers.  You can also get two mattresses and push them together on one bed frame, or opt to sleep in individual beds—either in the same room, or in two different ones.

Apart from that, buyers should look at very thick models with superior motion control.  This will give both the support they need, comfort to reduce joint pain, and enough stability to avoid that “sink and roll” combination so many mattresses cause.


Best Mattress for Overweight Couples Reviews

1. Gramercy Euro-Top Cool-Gel Memory Foam and Innerspring 14” Hybrid from Classic Brands Review

Classic Brands Decker Hybrid Memory Foam and Innerspring 10.5”

With the unbeatable support of traditional innersprings and contoured relief of memory foam, the Gramercy from Classic Brands combines modern comfort with time-tested design.  Like most hybrids, it pulls elements from both to get the benefits of each, while trying to diminish the downsides each brings to the table, too.

Pros

  • check
    Hybrid design is highly recommended for overweight individuals (or couples where one partner is overweight).
  • check
    Individually wrapped/pocketed coils for “squeak-free” support and excellent motion isolation.
  • check
    Gel-infused memory foam top layer for body heat dispersal.
  • check
    Euro-top provides a plush firmness.
  • check
    Customer service is available 7 days a week.

Cons

  • Edge is not reinforced; buyers might find it sinks too much when they sit on the bed or roll close to the edge while sleeping.

This hybrid is excellent for most overweight couples, because it’s both firm enough to provide stability and not sink when you lie down, but still soft enough to cushion joints and conform to your body, no matter what position you sleep in.  Other than the fact the edge isn’t reinforced, we think this will be a strong contender in most buyers’ hunts.  The low price might just make it the winner, too.

2. Signature Sleep Signature 13” Hybrid with Bamboo Cover Review

Signature Sleep Signature 13” Hybrid with Bamboo Cover

Another budget-friendly hybrid, this 13” model from Signature Sleep has 10” of support from encased coils, as well as 3” of high-density foam.  This bed promises firm support, equal weight distribution, and superior motion separation…but can it deliver?

Pros

  • check
    Bamboo-rayon mattress cover is durable and good at wicking away moisture; perfect for hot sleepers.
  • check
    CentiPUR-US certified high-density foam.
  • check
    13.5 gauge springs in middle for adequate “give” and weight distribution, but 15 gauge springs around edges for reinforcement.
  • check
    Medium-firm.

Cons

  • Might feel too firm for lighter partners in mixed-weight couples.

3. Eco Terra 11” Medium-Firm Luxury Latex Mattress Review

Eco Terra 11

While the name suggests otherwise, this model isn’t 100% latex; it’s actually another hybrid!  The medium-firm feel comes courtesy of its inner network of isolated coils, while the all-natural latex in the top layer delivers an ultra-responsive cushion.

Pros

  • check
    All-natural latex foam is comfortable, but doesn’t sink/compress the way memory foam does.  Natural also means less off-gassing after decompression (which means less/no “foam smell” after unpacking).
  • check
    Excellent motion separation.
  • check
    Higher gauge coils at edges for reinforcement; allegedly 26% more durable than mattresses without this.
  • check
    Medium-firm, towards the firmer end.
  • check
    Latex retains less body heat than memory foam overall.

Cons

  • Might be too firm for lighter partners.
  • At the higher end of many budgets.

If you’re tired of that “sinking feeling” you get from traditional memory foam, consider this alternative from Eco Terra.  Latex has a much greater bounce-back than foam, which means it supports you and relieves pressure as you move, but doesn’t contour and compress excessively under your weight.  This model should hold up better than many others, which are prone to sags and dips—latex takes much longer to break down, and the addition of innersprings provides even higher durability.

4. Ultimate Sleep Overweight Bariatric Mattress Review

Ultimate Sleep Overweight

So far, we’ve looked at mainstream options—mattresses from big brands, not marketed to specific weights or sizes, with pretty broad appeal.  This one is different, however, because it’s especially designed for people in the 300 to 400 lbs. range.  The company also sells models for weights above 400 lbs., if needed.

Pros

  • check
    Breathable cotton cover; helps wick away moisture.
  • check
    High-resiliency base and 5” of Talalay latex; strong support that contours broadly to weight, rather than conforming very closely like memory foam; eliminates that “sinking” feeling and helps mattress retain shape longer.

Cons

  • Considerably pricy.

The generous latex layering of this model seems like it will work for very overweight sleepers in a way most mattresses can’t, so perhaps the price is worth it.  If you’ve been disappointed by too many mainstream mattresses, this might be the one for you.  On the other hand, for buyers less than 300 lbs., we wonder if other latex-based models (or hybrids) couldn’t do the same job for less.

To Conclude:

In general, overweight couples should look for medium-firm or firm models, and designs that will provide the support, ventilation, and motion separation they need to sleep comfortably.  The hunt can be a difficult one, for sure—but with smart shopping and diligent research, you can find the perfect bed for both of you.